“It’s impossible entirely understand Marx’s Resource, and especially its earliest part, without thoroughly analyzed and you may realized the whole regarding Hegel’s Logic.Therefore, 50 years later not one of the Marxists understood Marx!”
Various other facet of the build out-of Funding that is lit because of the the fresh training of Hegel is the matter-of the relationship from actual historical invention in order to Marx’s complaints
Marx says in his Postface for the next edition out of Regularity step one off Funding that his system is none other than the latest dialectic. That isn’t, not, an immediate application of the new Hegelian dialectic. To the contrary, Marx tells us that the dialectic in Hegel-according to the excursion and you will care about-growth of the concept, where the world is actually a consequence or “exterior appearance”-is exactly the contrary out-of his own. With Marx we have an excellent materialist dialectic where Suggestion is actually good “reflection” of the real life unlike their writer . Yet Marx also goes on to-name himself a “scholar of these great thinker [Hegel],” and you may claims that “mystification indonesiancupid login which the dialectic endures inside the Hegel’s give certainly not inhibits your regarding as being the first presenting their standard models of movement inside an intensive and you will mindful fashion,” calling new “rational kernel” intrinsic inside Hegel’s dialectic “crucial and you will leading edge” .
Where certain (in the Structuralist and you can Logical camps) have seen an entire rejection out of Hegel, anybody else (regarding broadly “Western” and you may Humanist camps) have seen an essential continuity among them thinkers. That it concern has actually wondering myself since i first discovered Marx half dozen in years past. We surmise one to its strengths try all the more apparent to me personally as the my personal introduction so you’re able to Marx wasn’t the newest Communist Manifesto (as is the circumstances with a lot of contemporary customers), but alternatively Erich Fromm’s Marx’s Notion of Boy.
Much is made of those responses toward Marx’s relationship to Hegel, as well as of the dating simpliciter
If only below to temporarily examine two regions of Money and you will Marxism as a whole that will be considerably lit by training away from Hegel, especially the Phenomenology regarding Soul additionally the Technology of Reason: (1) the latest dialectical structure of Marx’s feedback, and you can (2) the difference between abstract and you will concrete negativity.
Marx starts their research of one’s “wealth of societies where in actuality the capitalist form from manufacturing is present” with what seems to be (but is indeed maybe not) by far the most tangible function distinguishable therein-the fresh new product . You will find arrive at realize that that it 1st step bears far more than just an excellent coincidental resemblance so you’re able to Hegel’s individual throughout the Phenomenology of Spirit . Truth be told there, Hegel begins his examination of the new enchanting development of understanding of its appear to extremely concrete means: Sense-Confidence. Right away, but not, Hegel reveals us how that it “bare truth away from confidence… is actually and you will undoubtedly the fresh abstractest and you can poorest particular truth” . At exactly the same time, to begin with a diagnosis of your own capitalist means out-of production which have the fresh product given that an “elementary setting” would be to begin with many relatively real-however,, indeed, really conceptual- point away from deviation. Hegel and you will Marx try each other quick to exhibit just how these origins, chosen because of the specific as they sustain the newest superficial draw regarding immediacy, harbor within this him or her irreconcilable contradictions. It’s the growth of these types of contradictions, owing to negativity, that capture every one of them the way to the best and extremely concrete forms inside their respective scientific analyses. Ergo, inside the Marx’s own investigation inside the Investment, we see how important contradiction during the product setting-the latest duality ranging from their replace-well worth and its particular use-value-was unfolded towards the next variations (exchange-well worth, currency, excessive value, financing…) by the a steady means of diremption and you may going back with the thinking in the high and real stages of development.
Whether or not it have to be said only: Marx is not creating history when you look at the Financial support-about he or she is not crudely reporting record. Quite the opposite, the brand new versions that he’s considering aren’t fundamentally quit shortly after highest forms supercede him or her, like they certainly were deserted from the chronological previous. Neither, for that matter, will be versions we find in the Marx’s analysis considered regarding buy where they look historically (even though some crude interaction can be found, just like Hegel’s Phenomenology). Alternatively, all the variations are ‘moments’ from a entirety this is the process of growth of the latest capitalist social formation.
Commentaires récents